Page 1 of 4

LDD SOmewhat Robotech-ish Mecha

Posted: Wed Jan 11, 2012 10:07 pm
by BrikSaber
I was screwing around on LDD, and I made this:
Image

Re: LDD SOmewhat Robotech-ish Mecha

Posted: Wed Jan 11, 2012 10:14 pm
by Whiteagle
Ok... ow...

And I thought my mecha attempts were bad...

Re: LDD SOmewhat Robotech-ish Mecha

Posted: Wed Jan 11, 2012 10:15 pm
by Whiteagle
BrikSaber wrote:
Whiteagle wrote:Ok... ow...

And I thought my mecha attempts were bad...
And this is why I never try to build them IRL.
Well I don't fault you for the style you were going for... but the joints are just... wrong...

Re: LDD SOmewhat Robotech-ish Mecha

Posted: Wed Jan 11, 2012 10:23 pm
by RagnarokRose
I like the design you were going for, but the gigantic fucking dancing dog that was the size of the photo kept me from analyzing the joint structure. Jesus.

Re: LDD SOmewhat Robotech-ish Mecha

Posted: Wed Jan 11, 2012 10:51 pm
by Insert_blank
I ran into the same problem with a steampunk-ish mech I built last winter (there are no pics unfortunately but I built it almost totally out of the Battle for Naboo set and the legs were from the Mandalorian Battle Pack) where the legs were too close together. I think if you try to space the legs apart more the look will be much improved and stability will also fix itself.

Re: LDD SOmewhat Robotech-ish Mecha

Posted: Wed Jan 11, 2012 11:54 pm
by OneEye589
Those joints would never hold.

Re: LDD SOmewhat Robotech-ish Mecha

Posted: Thu Jan 12, 2012 3:47 am
by Zahru II
I can see this work, though only after a couple of revisions and as stated before, with stronger joints.

Re: LDD SOmewhat Robotech-ish Mecha

Posted: Thu Jan 12, 2012 5:24 am
by Keldoclock
As it is now, it would literally buckle under it's own weight every time. Maybe some of these? Image

I use em for joints 'cause they're the only ones I have.

Re: LDD SOmewhat Robotech-ish Mecha

Posted: Thu Jan 12, 2012 10:37 am
by Whiteagle
Keldoclock wrote:As it is now, it would literally buckle under it's own weight every time. Maybe some of these? Image

I use em for joints 'cause they're the only ones I have.
Yeah, I think some #30552 or #30553 cylinder hinges with #43093 friction axle pins coupled with their corresponding plate or brick hinges would be much better joints.

At least for the arms anyways, you might need something heavier for the legs.

Re: LDD SOmewhat Robotech-ish Mecha

Posted: Thu Jan 12, 2012 3:58 pm
by enders_shadow
or you could get the 2x2 brick with a technic piece attached, those make for excellent joints (too lazy to bricklink, sorry)

Re: LDD SOmewhat Robotech-ish Mecha

Posted: Thu Jan 12, 2012 4:10 pm
by Whiteagle
enders_shadow wrote:or you could get the 2x2 brick with a technic piece attached, those make for excellent joints (too lazy to bricklink, sorry)
You mean like #57910 or #92013?

Yeah, I would have suggested those, but everyone here apparently hates ball joints...

Re: LDD SOmewhat Robotech-ish Mecha

Posted: Thu Jan 12, 2012 9:24 pm
by Joshua A.C. Newman
Ball joints are neat, particularly the new Hero Factory ones. They aren't particularly strong though.

The amount of squeezery put out by the hand-clips is much smaller than the tile-modified ones.

You can see how I was doing it here. It looks like the first image has bitrotted away, but you can see the knees in lower images. I use a lot of pneumatic Ts but taps are a much cheaper alternative.

You're also going for a shape of leg that doesn't exist in nature. I recommend going to the master (evolution) if you want something to work well and look "right".

Dig the feet, btw.

Re: LDD SOmewhat Robotech-ish Mecha

Posted: Thu Jan 12, 2012 10:06 pm
by enders_shadow
Whiteagle wrote:
enders_shadow wrote:or you could get the 2x2 brick with a technic piece attached, those make for excellent joints (too lazy to bricklink, sorry)
You mean like #57910 or #92013?

Yeah, I would have suggested those, but everyone here apparently hates ball joints...
no, not those, the ones with technic pieces sticking out (the most relevant example I can remember right now are the Ninjago dragons... they have the joints I'm talking about)

Re: LDD SOmewhat Robotech-ish Mecha

Posted: Fri Jan 13, 2012 10:38 am
by Whiteagle
Joshua A.C. Newman wrote:Ball joints are neat, particularly the new Hero Factory ones. They aren't particularly strong though.

The amount of squeezery put out by the hand-clips is much smaller than the tile-modified ones.

You can see how I was doing it here. It looks like the first image has bitrotted away, but you can see the knees in lower images. I use a lot of pneumatic Ts but taps are a much cheaper alternative.
Josh, your link is broken...
Plus I don't think clip-joints would be strong enough for a build this size anyways...
enders_shadow wrote:
Whiteagle wrote:
enders_shadow wrote:or you could get the 2x2 brick with a technic piece attached, those make for excellent joints (too lazy to bricklink, sorry)
You mean like #57910 or #92013?

Yeah, I would have suggested those, but everyone here apparently hates ball joints...
no, not those, the ones with technic pieces sticking out (the most relevant example I can remember right now are the Ninjago dragons... they have the joints I'm talking about)
Uh... Enders, you are going to have to be more spesific, since #92013 IS in three of the Ninjago Dragon sets...

Re: LDD SOmewhat Robotech-ish Mecha

Posted: Fri Jan 13, 2012 10:58 am
by Joshua A.C. Newman
Link works for me.

Use two tile-modified clips on a sing P-t. It's amazingly strong, plus you get another degree of freedom where you plug in the T.

A really, really strong, dense joint is this knee. Its the same as this one.