The BrikWars Forums

Hmm. I'm not sure if I'd rate this *confused*

Gameplay: 5
Photography: 5
Violence: 5
Writing: 5
Overall appeal: 5

FUCK YES THE PLAN WORKED [kind of] MOTHER FUCKERSSSSSSS

Gamplay:3
Photography:4
Violence:4
Overall appeal:4

Mhmm maybe we should give Natalya another price?
p.s. I don't understand why Silverdream had to troll. Natalya asked if she could participate with her turn/battle. Edit: There's one thing i don't understand. What will happen if Piltogg has all the artifax? He would be completetly op and that is boring. And i don't understand why it's so "easy" for him to get all the artifax. At the beginning of a QoP battle i'm sure that he will get the artifax he is searching for at the end..boring sometimes.

Germanico wrote:p.s. I don't understand why Silverdream had to troll. Natalya asked if she could participate with her turn/battle.

I trolled Natalya because it seemed a little unfair to bring a battle that had been going on for months to a recent competition. Trolling is how I express myself. But I guess it would be dickish of me to keep trolling her without any mercy. I'll give Natalya a fair score.

Silverdream wrote:GAMEPLAY: 0.625
PHOTOGRAPHY: 0.625
VIOLENCE: 0.625
WRITING: 0.5
OVERALL APPEAL: 0.625

x8=

Silverdream wrote:GAMEPLAY: 5
PHOTOGRAPHY: 5
VIOLENCE: 5
WRITING: 4
OVERALL APPEAL: 5

Yeah, I agree with Silverdream, as great as the Quest of Piltogg is, you can't really put the last turn of a forum battle that has been going on for months as a battle report.

I know there's no rule saying you can't, but

Silva's first post in this thread is exactly how this turn of the battle should be rated.

Silverdream wrote:This battle makes no sense. Who is fighting? How did the Akkadian get in the tank? What is going on?

Randomness is good, but it seems like you're missing most of the battle. As such I refuse to rate this obscene mess.

Otherwise I could say that the Fall of Fico was in previous turns of my battle and you would have to rate mine based on that.

I'm not on the HH judging team, but I think it's fine if each judge judges according to their own arbitrary feelings on how judging should work. If it were me I'd judge the qualities of this turn by itself, as opposed to judging the battle as a whole, and not worry too much about it.

Actually, I think Silva's one-eighth scoring system is pretty funny. But I like my arbitrary rules more.

Paco wrote:Yeah, I agree with Silverdream, as great as the Quest of Piltogg is, you can't really put the last turn of a forum battle that has been going on for months as a battle report.

I know there's no rule saying you can't, but

You should have thought of that before. You can't expect people to act by rules they don't know about. And Natalya didn't exactly have it easy.

I also rated this round by itself rather than the whole battle. The appearance of an AC, the terrain, and the hordes of figs, along with everything else, still means it surpasses other battle reports even though it's only one turn in my eyes. Well except for Zupponn's because I thought that one was legendary and the culmination of everything that is this forum for whole other reasons.

*cry* Somebody could help me to my questions?

If Piltogg gets too OP, we'll just have to start a new quest to find more Artifax to counter him. Always look at the new possibilities, not the problem

Germanico wrote:Mhmm maybe we should give Natalya another price?
p.s. I don't understand why Silverdream had to troll. Natalya asked if she could participate with her turn/battle. Edit: There's one thing i don't understand. What will happen if Piltogg has all the artifax? He would be completetly op and that is boring. And i don't understand why it's so "easy" for him to get all the artifax. At the beginning of a QoP battle i'm sure that he will get the artifax he is searching for at the end..boring sometimes.

I let him have it because, I mean, what the hell am I going to do with it? It was more fun to try to kill his dudes than to stop one man anyway. Also, it doesn't make Piltogg any better to get the Head Separator because he already has the Sword of Inhuman Strength and the Original OTC which means he essentially has 3 ungodly weapons, except they are all hand-wielded close-combat weapons, so it would be hard for him to use them all at the same time. The combo flamer-assault rifle that he traded for it is way cooler IMO. Additionally, where would the story go if he didn't get all the Artifakts? It would go nowhere.

At least this way, if he's going to become OP, at least everyone got to participate in a massive forum battle with literally hundreds of minifigs, something like 10 vehicles, decapitations, explosions, flamethrower incinerations, lasers, bullets, missiles, cars driving through walls, tanks driving through walls, an AC lifting people off the wall, monstrous beasts ripping people in half, a METAL concert, a riot, people getting catapulted across part of the map, jet-pack troopers, combat hardsuits, ninja assassinations, and a merch booth. I mean, for real. Maybe Piltogg gets to be more OP, but in return I brought you the biggest and bloodiest battle of 2012.

Natalya wrote:I brought you the biggest and bloodiest battle of 2012.